No. Medication
can be helpful, when combined with cognitive-behavioral therapy,
but it is not able to produce permanent changes in your brain.
By actually learning new ways to think and by slowly (and
in a non-pressuring way) acting on these thoughts, your
brain pathways actually change physiologically, and this brings
about a gradual, permanent change in your feelings.
2.
I’ve heard that cognitive-behavioral therapy is stressful. Is
this true?
Although
cognitive-behavioral therapy is an active, focused treatment, it
can never be deliberately stressful or pressuring in nature or it
will not work with socially-anxious people. Instead,
cognitive-behavioral treatment is gentle, challenging, and works
by "hierarchy" (moving up one step at a time).
3.
I was told I should "force" myself
into difficult anxiety-producing situations and I would get over
my social anxiety.
The advice to
"flood" yourself with high anxiety so that you will get
better does NOT work for people with social anxiety. The
attempt to perform an activity that is highly anxiety-arousing
almost guarantees failure for the person. This, in turn, leads to
further embarrassment, humiliation, and depression.
4.
If forcing myself into social situations doesn't work, how
will I ever get better?
It is important
to start more slowly and gradually work up
gently to the place you'd like to be. We always use cognitive (re-thinking)
methods and strategies first to provide the person with a foundation
of new thinking skills and anti-anxiety strategies that
are beginning to "sink down" deeply into the brain so
that they become a habit or an automatic
behavior. We feel therapy is much more successful if these
cognitive strategies are learned and deeply dropped into the
brain first. Then, when a person feels less social anxiety and a
little more confident, they decide to move into the social
anxiety therapy group where changes in behaviors are worked on
more directly. However, we make it a rule that no one is ever
forced, challenged, or urged to do anything they don't feel like
doing in the group. The motivation and impetus must come directly
from the person with social anxiety. We have found this approach
to group therapy to be most effective.
5.
I think I would just sit there in group and be scared to
death. How many people get up enough nerve to actually do
something during the group therapy meetings?
We wouldn't
admit you into the group until you felt a little more
confident about your abilities. That is the purpose of the
cognitive therapy emphasis during individual sessions. Of course, everyone is anxious during the first group therapy
sessions, but the promise that no one will be singled out, asked
to say anything, or put on display makes everyone feel more
comfortable. Also, we never do the "introduction" game
of going around the circle and introducing ourselves at the first
meeting (socially-anxious people will fully understand this one!)
The rule is that no one ever has to do anything they don't want
to do.
As a result,
we've never run a therapy group where an individual hasn't wanted
to work on their anxiety in social situations. We follow a
specific, but fluid, hierarchy or "ladder" of
anxiety-causing behaviors for each individual, but it is always
the person with social anxiety that has full control over what is
actually done.
6.
I have a psychiatrist and a psychologist, but I felt like
I knew more than both of them by researching Social Phobia on the
net and reading Dying of Embarrassment.
I
know I can conquer this fear, and I also know that I am going to
need some good coaching from someone who knows what they are
talking about. Thank you for your time and suggestions.
You are correct -- your assessment is right on target. At
present, we don't know of any social anxiety therapists in your
area, but I will attach a text message showing you how to access
the Anxiety Disorders Association of America therapy pages. The
only problem with this strategy is that anyone who pays dues can
join. Therefore, before you make any appointments, call and check
the therapist out first and make sure they understand what
social phobia is. Because if they don't know what it is, how
will they know how to coach you out of it? Yes, I think several
of our articles on The Anxiety Network -- Social Phobia/Social
Anxiety Home Page -- address this issue of finding the right
therapist. Take care. Let me know what you find out and how
you're doing.
7.
First off let me say thanks for the quick reply! I really
appreciate your advice, and that you take the time to help a
total stranger, and yes,
I'm
one of those that decided a long time ago, "I'll just live
with it." I'll tell you a little
about my anxiety problems and will try not to be too boring. When
it started, I was out with my friend smoking pot, which I had
done quite often in the past. This particular time I was higher
than I'd ever been. This was during school lunch hour. I got back
to school and was too paranoid to go back to class so I went to
the bathroom and started eating my lunch I'd brought. Suddenly, I
felt my heart racing...this was the main symptom I recall back
then, and as you'd expect, I thought I was dying...a heart
attack? I wasn't sure, but I knew something was wrong. I ran and
got help and was taken to a hospital.
They
checked me out and said I was fine....nothing wrong with me.
Well, it went away and I didn't think much more about it. A
couple of days went by, and I got high again. Sure enough, I had
another anxiety attack. This time I just had a feeling
of.....well, I guess it was sort of like unreality......and a
general fear that I was dying. I went home immediately and told
my parents I was going to die and they sat with me. I guess the
anxiety fed on itself because I became worse and started to
hyperventilate. Another trip to the hospital and I got the same
result. "There's nothing wrong with you". So what you
said made sense -- hearing that nothing was wrong with me made
it worse.
I
thought, "Yes, there is, but you don't know what it is! I
must have something wrong with my mind that nobody else
has." I was having a severe panic attack, but the bad part
was it wasn't like a normal one. I got home from the hospital and
it didn't get better. The attack stayed the same strength. It was
like a permanent panic attack.
Somehow
my mother was told that I might have an anxiety disorder. She
talked to a doctor at a mental hospital and they told her I
should be taken to them. I told my mother I was going to kill
myself because I couldn't take this, so that was all she needed
to hear and she took me to the mental hospital.
At
the mental hospital they told me I had anxiety attacks, and that
was about it. My doctor even said he didn't know anything about
how to help with it besides giving me medicine. I tried taking
the medicine he gave me and it made the anxiety worse somehow.
After 3 days I still had VERY strong anxiety. Not all the
symptoms but I would say the majority of them. Still, though, it
was nonstop. It didn't peak and then get better.....then attack
again.....it was like I said: permanent. I couldn't stop moving.
I felt my heart beating in my ears and chest. I had terrible
chest discomfort and muscle tension. There was bizarre feelings I
can't describe....unreality maybe.....thought I was going
crazy.....after a week maybe. it finally got a
little better. but I associated this anxiety with drugs (pot) so
in the end it turned out to be ANY
drugs.. .including aspirin and antibiotics.....that would give
me a panic attack. I had anticipatory anxiety just from thinking
about taking them.
What
helped me, I think, was the fact that I became more and more
suicidal. I started not caring if this killed me. In fact, I
hoped it would. I quit worrying if my heart beating fast would
kill me so it didn't beat like that anymore. I didn't care if I
suffocated so I breathed pretty normal.
Years later, I was forced to take certain medicine because of
REAL medical problems and they didn't bother me like I feared
they would. I even drink on occasion now. Every once in awhile
I'll wake up in the morning after drinking and will have an
anxiety attack that lasts about 1 or 2 days, but it's mild. The
muscle tension being the main thing that
bothers me. That's my worst symptom now. I haven't smoked pot and
the serious contemplation it gives me anxious thoughts.....so I
have stayed away from it. I don't take medicine usually unless I
REALLY need it, but my panic in general is very mild compared to
what it once was. It's either gotten better...or just evolved in
some way to something different.
This was long I
know.....sorry. but it's still just a basic and rushed
explanation of how it has been.
As to the
social phobia.....this will be quicker. My whole life I have been
very shy. That is, until I became fairly close friends with
someone -- then I can become a leader. I can be outgoing as
anyone. A few years after I started having panic attacks this
"shyness" became worse. The job I have now is a good
example of how I am today. My mother became very very mad at me
because I sat around the house doing nothing useful. No job...no
school...just doing nothing. She told me to get off my butt and
get a job.
I WANTED
one...I needed money.....but I was deathly afraid to even try. No
references...and I felt very uncomfortable at the thought of
going in for an interview. I didn't understand this. Why was I so
afraid? I thought maybe I was lazy. I finally forced myself to
apply to a few jobs and amazingly, I thought, one had me come in
for an interview. The interview went as you would expect (me
jumbling words and trying to blow it), but they hired me anyway.
I think it was about a whole month before I actually had a real
conversation with any of my co-workers. I'm pretty comfortable
there now, but still if there is any staff meetings or training
classes, it's just like the stories on your page. Feelings that
people are watching or criticizing....picking on me and secretly
laughing inside. That's work though.
I have no
social life anymore. I don't like people, is what I say. I get on
the internet, or read books, play my Sony playstation.....and I
feel completely comfortable. Now anytime I go out in the
public.....deal with anyone.....or just walk down the street I
feel so uncomfortable I just want to get out of there as fast as
I can. When I first meet a stranger I say maybe, "how are
you doing?" and "my name's Jason". That's about
it. That never happens though now....I don't associate with
ANYONE now. My home is my haven.
To summarize:
my panic attacks are very mild now, so I don't think about it as
much. This social phobia on the other hand....you know how you
think, 'nobody could ever feel like I'm feeling now'? Your
page is why I said I was shocked! I related so well with it that
I'm now POSITIVE I have it. Every way you described it sounded
like myself. While I think I still have panic, I'm not sure if
it's possibly related to this social phobia. Maybe I have both or
it's just the one? What do you think? And thanks again...you made
me also realize that this depression I have is most likely caused
by one or both of these things we are talking about. By the way,
I read everything on your page. All the links.
I made an
appointment with a mental health care facility for this coming
Monday. They told me they have people that are trained to
deal with social phobias. They didn't say if those trained were
specialized in it, but I'll find out Monday. If you could tell me
some good questions to ask to find out if they are the councilors
I need, it would be a great help. Once again I thank you for your
time and help and hope this HUGE boring letter does not disgust
too much.
Answer:
First of all, your e-mail was not boring or
disgusting at all. It was both interesting and helpful. Because I
had social anxiety for 20 years myself, I can feel everything
you're feeling and I know it isn't fun. You're not crazy; there's
nothing wrong with you except for the current social anxiety and the depression that always goes along with it.
I wish you lived closer because it is my joy in life to work with
social phobia people and see them overcome this disorder and walk
into new lives. That is why I get up every morning.
Yes, it does sound as if you had classic symptoms of panic
disorder when you were a teenager. And it does sound like panic
has bled over into social anxiety more strongly now. That is what
I meant on the pages: One or the other anxiety disorder is
usually dominant, at any one given time. Today, however, from
what you write, it sounds like the social anxiety symptoms are
more prevalent.
I'm glad that you're seeking help; the only problem, as I've
mentioned is that social anxiety (although it affects 8% of the
American population) is never heard about -- and
psychologists/therapists are not trained in graduate school as to
its definition, let alone as how to overcome it through
cognitive-behavioral therapy.
8. Ask questions of your
therapist such as:
"How much
of your practice is geared toward people with social
phobia?" (They can't simply answer "yes" or
"no" to this question.)
"I was
told all my life that most of my problem was panic. Now someone
has told me it may be social anxiety. Can you tell me what the
symptoms of social anxiety are?" Make THEM tell YOU what the
symptoms are so that you can check to see if they truly
understand the disorder.
Then,
because research has been clear that cognitive-behavioral therapy
is the only effective therapy for overcoming social anxiety, ask
what changing your "cognitions" (thoughts) means -- and
HOW ARE THEY GOING TO DO THAT? If they say you two are going to
"talk" about it, stop! Remember talking about your
anxiety over and over again just depresses us more -- and then we
never make any progress.
Your
therapist should have specific methods, techniques, and
strategies all written down (printed) on handouts that explains
what to practice and WHY (the rationale behind it or how it will
make you better over time). For example, we have over 200
handouts here that we use with our social anxiety people -- every
week we move forward, learn new methods of dealing with social
anxiety, and eventually put them into practice so that they are
permanent changes the brain makes.
They should
also have a behavioral therapy group for people with social
anxiety. After individual CBT (when you're feeling stronger and
better about yourself, you begin a group of 5-10 people who are
also people with social anxiety and you work on the things (such
as making introductions around the room, speaking in a small
group, etc.) very slowly and gradually so that your successes
build up.
Group therapy
nights are always my favorite nights of the week, because even
though I know my people are a little anxious, they will be making
more progress and moving closer to their goal. Everyone here who
has gone through the behavioral group(s) has moved up and forward
-- either into college or a return to college, into a job, into a
new job, or they've been able to accept a promotion to the level
they are more capable of -- because now they know how to handle
the anxiety.
I know. It
happened to me and I've seen it happen now to dozens and dozens
of others. Sometimes the going is rough, but if you find the
right therapist and stick with it, you WILL get better and then
gradually overcome the whole thing. It is very positive. The only
hindrance to all this is -- we need more therapists who know what
to do.
--
Thomas A. Richards, Ph.D., Psychologist
"Overcoming
Social Anxiety": The 20 session audio therapy series
Back
to Top
|